This essay explores these questions, offering a polemic against Sharia law as a significant hindrance to development in Muslim-majority countries. Simultaneously, it acknowledges the West's weaknesses, particularly the decline associated with the diminishing influence of Christianity.
By Dr. Tim Orr
In the contemporary global landscape, stark contrasts exist between nations, particularly when comparing Muslim-majority countries and Western governments. A United Nations report highlights that Muslim-majority countries significantly lag behind most of the world, except sub-Saharan Africa, in terms of democracy, human rights, and modernization (United Nations, 2021). This disparity invites a critical examination of the underlying factors contributing to these differences. What historical, cultural, and religious dynamics are at play? Why is the West often perceived as superior, especially in democratic governance, respect for human rights, and societal progress? This blog explores these questions, offering a belief that Sharia law is a significant hindrance to development in Muslim-majority countries. Simultaneously, it will acknowledge the weaknesses of the West, particularly the decline associated with the diminishing influence of Christianity. This discussion aims to provide a nuanced understanding of these complex issues through real-life illustrations, comprehensive analysis, and scholarly references.
The developmental lag in Muslim-majority countries can be traced back to significant historical events. The decline of the Ottoman Empire, which marked a turning point in the Islamic world, led to a prolonged period of stagnation and failed modernization attempts. For instance, once a dominant force, the Ottoman Empire faced significant military defeats and territorial losses, signaling its weakening grip (Lewis, 2002). The empire's inability to modernize and adapt to new technologies and governance models further exacerbated its decline.
In contrast, Western nations undergoing the Industrial Revolution experienced rapid technological, governance, and economic advancements. This period of industrialization not only propelled Western nations to global dominance but also laid the foundation for modern democratic societies. The historical divergence set the stage for the contrasting developmental trajectories observed today.
One of the most significant barriers to modernization in Muslim-majority countries is the lack of separation between religion and state. In countries like Saudi Arabia and Iran, Islamic principles and Sharia law heavily influence governance, legal systems, and societal norms (Esposito, 2010). This integration of religion into state affairs often results in resistance to reforms perceived as contrary to Islamic values.
In contrast, the West has a long history of evolving towards separating church and state. For example, the United States Constitution enshrines the principle of secular governance, allowing secular institutions to develop and foster environments where scientific inquiry, technological advancement, and social reforms can flourish independently of religious dogma (Feldman, 2005). The ability to critique and reform societal structures without religious interference is a hallmark of Western societies and a significant factor in their perceived superiority.
Democracy, characterized by free and fair elections, the rule of law, and the protection of individual rights, has been a cornerstone of Western success. The democratic framework encourages accountability, transparency, and public participation in governance, leading to more responsive and effective governments (Dahl, 2000). For instance, countries like Norway and Sweden consistently rank high on democratic indices and human development metrics due to their robust democratic institutions (Freedom House, 2021).
In contrast, many Muslim-majority countries grapple with authoritarian regimes, corruption, and a lack of political freedoms. The concentration of power in the hands of a few, often justified by religious or traditional authority, stifles innovation and impedes the development of robust institutions. For example, Egypt has experienced prolonged authoritarian rule, limiting political freedoms and hindering democratic governance (Brownlee, 2012).
The West's emphasis on human rights and individual freedoms is another area of perceived superiority. Western societies prioritize protecting individual rights, including freedom of speech, assembly, and religion. These rights are enshrined in legal frameworks and upheld by independent judiciaries, ensuring individuals can live free from oppression and discrimination (Sen, 2009).
Conversely, many Muslim-majority countries face significant human rights challenges. For example, in Saudi Arabia, women’s rights are severely restricted, with women requiring a male guardian’s permission for various activities (Doumato, 2010). Issues such as gender inequality, restrictions on freedom of expression, and discrimination against religious minorities are prevalent. These human rights violations are often justified on religious grounds, creating significant barriers to social progress and equality.
Sharia law is often cited as a significant factor contributing to the developmental lag in Muslim-majority countries. Derived from the Quran and Hadith, Sharia covers all aspects of a Muslim's life, including daily routines, familial and religious obligations, and financial dealings.
The Nature of Sharia Law: Sharia law is inherently ultra-conservative and resistant to change. It is based on texts over a millennium old and interprets them as immutable and divine. This rigidity hampers the ability of Muslim-majority countries to adapt to modern challenges and evolving societal norms. For instance, countries like Sudan have implemented strict Sharia laws that often clash with international human rights standards, resulting in international condemnation (Hale, 2012).
Impact on Women: Sharia law significantly impacts women’s rights. In many interpretations, women are afforded fewer rights than men in areas such as inheritance, testimony in court, and personal autonomy. For example, in Saudi Arabia, the guardianship system severely restricts women's freedoms (Doumato, 2010). These restrictions not only violate basic human rights but also limit women's participation in the workforce, hindering economic development.
Freedom of Expression: Sharia law often imposes severe restrictions on freedom of expression. Blasphemy and apostasy are considered serious crimes, punishable by death in some Muslim-majority countries. This creates an environment of fear and censorship, stifling intellectual discourse and innovation. In Pakistan, blasphemy laws have been used to target religious minorities and suppress dissent (Malik, 2012).
Judicial System: Implementing Sharia law in the judicial system often leads to arbitrary and harsh punishments, including corporal and capital punishment. The lack of separation between religious and secular law undermines the development of a fair and independent judiciary. Inconsistent application of justice and the influence of religious authorities over legal matters erode public trust in the legal system and impede the establishment of the rule of law (Brown, 1997).
Economic development in the West has been driven by industrialization, innovation, and a market-oriented approach. Despite its flaws, the capitalist model has spurred technological advancements and economic growth, lifting millions out of poverty and creating prosperous societies (Acemoglu & Robinson, 2012). Western nations have invested heavily in education, infrastructure, and research, fostering environments conducive to innovation and economic dynamism.
In contrast, many Muslim-majority countries have economies heavily reliant on natural resources, such as oil. While resource wealth can bring significant revenue, it often leads to economic dependency and a lack of diversification. For example, Saudi Arabia’s economy is heavily dependent on oil, making it vulnerable to fluctuations in oil prices (Hertog, 2010). Additionally, the lack of investment in education and infrastructure further hinders economic development and modernization efforts.
Cultural and social factors also play a crucial role in the developmental lag observed in Muslim-majority countries. Traditional values and norms, deeply rooted in Islamic teachings, often clash with modernizing influences. This clash can lead to social tensions and resistance to change, impeding progress in gender equality, education, and scientific research.
Western societies, on the other hand, have undergone significant cultural shifts over the past few centuries. The Enlightenment period, for example, emphasized reason, individualism, and scientific inquiry, challenging traditional authority and paving the way for modern democratic societies (Porter, 2001). The ability to question and reform cultural norms has been a significant driver of progress in the West, contributing to its perceived superiority.
Education is a cornerstone of societal development, and its role in the disparity between the West and Muslim-majority countries cannot be overstated. Western nations have historically valued education, investing in comprehensive public education systems and higher education institutions. These investments have created highly educated populations capable of driving innovation and economic growth (Goldin & Katz, 2008).
In many Muslim-majority countries, educational systems often lag due to underfunding, political instability, and cultural factors. In some cases, religious education takes precedence over secular education, limiting the scope of knowledge and critical thinking skills imparted to students. For instance, in Pakistan, madrassas focus primarily on religious instruction, often neglecting subjects like science and mathematics (Andrabi, Das, Khwaja, & Zajonc, 2006). The lack of access to quality education hampers human capital development, further entrenching underdevelopment and poverty.
Gender equality is a critical area where the West is often seen as superior. Western societies have made significant strides in advancing women's rights, including equal access to education, employment, and political participation. These advancements have improved women's lives and contributed to broader societal and economic progress (Inglehart & Norris, 2003).
In many Muslim-majority countries, gender inequality remains a significant issue. Cultural and religious norms often restrict women's roles in society, limiting their opportunities for education and employment. Discriminatory laws and practices, such as those related to inheritance, marriage, and dress codes, further entrench gender disparities. Addressing these issues is essential for achieving broader development goals and improving society's overall well-being.
It is also important to acknowledge the role of Western colonialism in shaping the current state of Muslim-majority countries. Colonial powers often imposed artificial borders, exploited resources, and disrupted traditional governance structures, leaving lasting legacies of instability and underdevelopment. The impacts of colonialism continue to influence political, economic, and social dynamics in many Muslim-majority countries (Young, 2001).
For example, the arbitrary borders drawn by colonial powers in Africa and the Middle East have contributed to ongoing ethnic and sectarian conflicts. The exploitation of resources by colonial powers left many countries with economies dependent on a single commodity, hindering diversification and sustainable development. Addressing these historical legacies is crucial for fostering long-term regional stability and development.
Conflict and instability are pervasive issues in many Muslim-majority countries, further hindering development. The Middle East, in particular, has been a focal point of geopolitical rivalries, leading to prolonged conflicts and instability. For instance, the Israeli-Palestinian conflict, the wars in Iraq and Afghanistan, and the Syrian civil war have had devastating effects on the region, leading to loss of life, displacement, and destruction of infrastructure (Gleditsch, Wallensteen, Eriksson, Sollenberg, & Strand, 2002).
These conflicts divert resources away from development and create environments where extremist ideologies can thrive, further destabilizing the region. The presence of armed groups, weak governance structures, and external interventions complicate efforts to achieve peace and stability. Addressing the root causes of these conflicts and promoting inclusive and sustainable peace processes are essential for fostering regional development.
While the West is often perceived as superior in development, it has weaknesses. One significant factor contributing to its decline is the loss of Christian influence in public and private life. Christianity, historically a cornerstone of Western civilization, provided a moral and ethical framework that shaped societal values, governance, and cultural norms.
Moral and Ethical Decline: The secularization of Western societies has led to a decline in traditional moral and ethical values. The erosion of the family unit, the rise of individualism, and the weakening of community bonds are often cited as consequences of this secularization. For instance, the increase in divorce rates and the prevalence of single-parent households are indicators of moral decline (Wilcox, 2010). The lack of a unifying moral framework can lead to social fragmentation and a loss of a sense of purpose and direction.
Decline in Civic Engagement: The decline of Christian influence has also been linked to a decrease in civic engagement and social responsibility. Christianity emphasized the importance of serving others and contributing to the common good. As religious participation declines, there is a corresponding decline in volunteerism, community involvement, and charitable activities, which can weaken the social fabric. Studies have shown that religious individuals are more likely to engage in civic activities and volunteer work than their secular counterparts (Putnam & Campbell, 2010).
Cultural Relativism: The rise of cultural relativism in the West, often associated with the decline of Christianity, has led to a reluctance to assert the superiority of Western values. This has created an environment where harmful practices, such as female genital mutilation or forced marriages, are tolerated in the name of cultural sensitivity. The unwillingness to uphold and promote universal human rights standards undermines global efforts to address these issues. For example, debates over accepting Sharia law in Western legal systems reflect this tension between cultural sensitivity and human rights (An-Na'im, 2008).
Political Polarization: Losing a common religious foundation has also increased political polarization in Western societies. Without a shared set of values and beliefs, societies become more divided along ideological lines, leading to gridlock, extremism, and social unrest. The weakening of Christianity as a unifying force has made finding common ground and working towards collective goals more challenging. The rise of populist movements and the increasing polarization of political discourse are manifestations of this broader societal divide (McCarty, Poole, & Rosenthal, 2006).
Economic Inequality: Economic inequality is another issue exacerbated by the decline of Christian influence. Christian teachings historically emphasized the importance of caring for the poor and addressing economic disparities. As these teachings lose their influence, there is a growing acceptance of economic inequality and a lack of political will to address the root causes of poverty and social injustice. The widening gap between the rich and the poor in many Western societies is a testament to this trend (Piketty, 2014).
The West's perceived superiority over Muslim-majority countries is rooted in historical, cultural, and structural differences. Western nations have benefited from democratic governance, respect for human rights, economic development, and cultural shifts that have fostered innovation and progress. In contrast, many Muslim-majority countries face challenges such as authoritarian regimes, human rights violations, economic dependency, and resistance to modernization due to rigid interpretations of Sharia law.
However, it is also essential to recognize the West's weaknesses, particularly its decline, as Christianity has lost its influence. The erosion of moral and ethical values, the decline in civic engagement, the rise of cultural relativism, political polarization, and economic inequality are significant challenges that Western societies must address.
Ultimately, addressing the developmental lag in Muslim-majority countries and the decline in the West requires a comprehensive and multifaceted approach. This involves promoting democratic governance, protecting human rights, investing in education, and fostering economic diversification. It also requires engaging with cultural and religious leaders to promote interpretations of Islam that support modernization and development and revitalize the moral and ethical foundations of Western societies. By addressing these issues, both the West and Muslim-majority countries can work towards a more just, equitable, and prosperous future.
Acemoglu, D., & Robinson, J. A. (2012). Why nations fail: The origins of power, prosperity, and poverty. Crown Publishers.
An-Na'im, A. A. (2008). Islam and the secular state: Negotiating the future of Sharia. Harvard University Press.
Andrabi, T., Das, J., Khwaja, A. I., & Zajonc, T. (2006). Religious school enrollment in Pakistan: A look at the data. Comparative Education Review, 50(3), 446-477.
Brown, N. J. (1997). The rule of law in the Arab world: Courts in Egypt and the Gulf. Cambridge University Press.
Brownlee, J. (2012). Democracy prevention: The politics of the U.S.-Egyptian alliance. Cambridge University Press.
Dahl, R. A. (2000). On democracy. Yale University Press.
Doumato, E. A. (2010). Saudi Arabia. In The Greenwood Encyclopedia of Women's Issues Worldwide (pp. 759-772). Greenwood Press.
Esposito, J. L. (2010). Islam: The straight path. Oxford University Press.
Feldman, N. (2005). Divided by God: America's church-state problem—and what we should do about it. Farrar, Straus and Giroux.
Freedom House. (2021). Freedom in the World 2021. Retrieved from Freedom House.
Gleditsch, N. P., Wallensteen, P., Eriksson, M., Sollenberg, M., & Strand, H. (2002). Armed conflict 1946-2001: A new dataset. Journal of Peace Research, 39(5), 615-637.
Goldin, C., & Katz, L. F. (2008). The race between education and technology. Harvard University Press.
Hale, S. M. (2012). Sudan's Islamist state: Islam and politics in a post-Colonial world. Lynne Rienner Publishers.
Hertog, S. (2010). Princes, brokers, and bureaucrats: Oil and the state in Saudi Arabia. Cornell University Press.
Inglehart, R., & Norris, P. (2003). Rising tide: Gender equality and cultural change around the world. Cambridge University Press.
Lewis, B. (2002). What went wrong? Western impact and Middle Eastern response. Oxford University Press.
Malik, I. H. (2012). The history of Pakistan. Greenwood Press.
McCarty, N., Poole, K. T., & Rosenthal, H. (2006). Polarized America: The dance of ideology and unequal riches. MIT Press.
Piketty, T. (2014). Capital in the twenty-first century. Harvard University Press.
Porter, R. (2001). The Enlightenment. Palgrave.
Putnam, R. D., & Campbell, D. E. (2010). American grace: How religion divides and unites us. Simon & Schuster.
Sen, A. (2009). The idea of justice. Harvard University Press.
United Nations. (2021). Human Development Report 2021. Retrieved from UNDP.
Wilcox, W. B. (2010). Soft patriarchy, new families: The rise of committed fathers and empowered mothers in America. University of Chicago Press.
Young, C. (2001). The African colonial state in comparative perspective. Yale University Press.
The ideas in this blog are mine, but AI was used to help create the content.